No Image Available

Annie Hayes



Read more about Annie Hayes

Quarter of HR don’t want payroll responsibility


New research has found that a quarter of finance professionals in charge of payroll would actually rather it was part of HR, yet almost the same number of their HR counterparts say they would rather it was part of finance.

ADP Employer Services, the payroll service provider, surveyed over 750 HR and finance professionals in charge of payroll and found that despite what many may think, payroll is actually more likely to sit under finance (49%) than HR (40%) with this number rising amongst smaller organisations (69% to 31%).

Don McGuire, managing director at ADP, said: “Payroll is important to both HR and finance, with both sides requiring the data and information that it provides. But there seems to be a lot of disagreement over who should take overall responsibility and a lack of best practice as to how the two departments should work together. The fact that so many HR and finance professionals feel that it shouldn’t sit in their department highlights that neither see it as part of their core job role.”

The survey found that less than half have any efficiency measures in place. Surprisingly, finance professionals actually fared worse with only 39% measuring efficiency compared to 49% in the HR department.

The research also found that a third of those in charge of payroll would not examine payroll expenditure (outside staff costs) when looking to cut costs in the business. With many respondents feeling that costs could be made on areas such as administration (52%) and minimising errors (43%), this could be an area where organisations are losing out.

McGuire said: “The wage bill accounts for 50 – 80% of an organisation’s expenditure and the costs of preparing payroll can be significant. In light of the current economic climate, businesses should be looking at areas where they can increase efficiency and cut costs. Payroll is one area that is often neglected.”

Despite this seeming reluctance to be involved in payroll, the majority of organisations (63%) still retain the function in-house, with this rising considerably among finance respondents (76%). Reasons for this include keeping control of data (86%), seeing no reason to change (84%) and security concerns (80%).

Of those respondents who outsource, 68% do so to a bureau service with the remainder outsourcing to a managed service. Reasons for doing so include freeing up internal staff time (82%), access to greater expertise (75%) and reducing costs (69%). Not surprisingly, finance professionals are significantly more likely to outsource due to the cost savings, with 88% agreeing this was a factor compared to only 66% of HR professionals.

No Image Available
Annie Hayes


Read more from Annie Hayes

Get the latest from HRZone.

Subscribe to expert insights on how to create a better workplace for both your business and its people.


Thank you.