Recognize This! – Unless star performers deliver results in the right way, they aren’t truly stars.

Think for a moment about your star employees – your top performers who can be counted on to get the job done and get it right.

Now, still thinking about those employees, ask yourself if these star employees also get the work done in the right way. Do they demonstrate the proper behaviours in line with your company’s core values, are do they bully, steamroll and steal credit?

In a recent Harvard Business Review article, Eric Sinoway argues top performers who get the job done, but don’t do it in the right way are, in fact, vampires and not stars. I couldn’t agree more. As Eric explains:

“Our company, Axcess Worldwide, was shaped in its early years by a small, tight knit group: my partner, Kirk Posmatur, and me and our first few employees. Now, after significant growth, we were honing our strategy, placing the right people in the right roles, continuing to deliver profitability whilst simultaneously maintaining a strong and meaningful corporate culture, something we consider to be one of our most powerful assets.

“The new executive we were discussing that day was doing what we had hired him to: immediately deliver results. But he was doing so in a manner that didn’t strike us as consistent with our culture; he was focussed so intensely on ‘what he did’ that he paid little attention to ‘how he did it,’ which resulted in consistently dismissing the opinions of others and pursuing what we felt was a strategy of ‘winning at any cost.’” … He was a cultural vampire. And so regardless of his functional performance, we had to terminate him.”

Negative Business Impact from Jerk Bosses

Too many will simply dismiss this, believing “as long as the work gets done, it doesn’t matter how.” Now, new research supports the cost to business of allowing jerk managers to continue in your organisation. Just look at these findings:

• 24% of employees thought their bosses were over-stressed, poor communicators and lacked empathy – a combination judged to be counterproductive and in some cases destructive by the report.
• Just 5% of workers said their managers led in a way that: meant they were empathetic; explained why organisational change was good to staff members as individuals; created workplaces in which employees felt rewarded for their efforts; and were self-aware.
• Only 35% of respondents said that, when their organisation needed to change, their boss personally made them aware of the benefits.
• Almost half (47%) of the 2,000 workers surveyed said that their managers made them feel threatened, rather than rewarded

If the boss can’t communicate to employees changing strategies and objectives, how employees are supposed to implement those changes in the daily work, or reward employees for doing so effectively, then change will not happen.

What do you do with the “zombie managers?” You have two choices – train them or fire them. If the manager is a bully nature, then your choice is easy. There should be no room for bullies in any organisation that promotes a strong, positive culture today.

What do “star performers” look like in your organisation?