There is a looming black hole in HR, careers advice and skills development that could blight a generation. HR professionals, in particular, will be facing some of the most challenging conditions seen in the UK since the 1930s.
The UK government wants to help but funds are limited. It wants people to embrace the idea of the Big Society and take action, but what are the commercial and social drivers, and how can HR professionals respond effectively over the next five to ten years?
Two main challenges are a clear skills gap, with employers struggling to find, engage with and select the most suitable candidates while there is the prospect of a million people unemployed through government cuts over the next five years. As an adjunct, education faces significant budget reductions as do the public sector careers advice services.
In this tough environment, companies will lean heavily on HR departments to manage more effective outreach that not only guides those being made redundant but also harnesses better ways to collaborate with constituent groups and communities.
HR centres are likely to become the regenerative hub of many companies, building new conduits for participation and partnerships with other departments that will fuel the employment and retention with the development of applicants, internal employees, student populations and community interest groups.
Education challenges
Research shows that young people believe that the careers guidance system has let them down at every level, from choosing the right school courses, to guidance on the best degree course or vocational training to graduates who have not been advised properly about their career choices.
The stark facts for employers are:
- 200,000 young people with the right grades failed to get into university this year. How will they make the right choices? How do employers engage with them?
- Cuts mean that up to 500,000 people in the public sector will lose their jobs over the next five years. What happens to them?
- Analysts have predicted a similar number losing their jobs in the private sector. Where do they go for guidance and advice?
- Young people say that the UK careers advice system is failing them
- Prime minister David Cameron says that the current Connexions careers advice system is not working
- Careers advice services in schools/colleges do the best they can but research this year shows that they are failing
Deirdre Hughes, 2010 president of the Institute of Career Guidance, believes that a solution is found in better online careers services and engagement. This should also benefit hard-pressed HR departments looking for precise and cost-effective ways to find recruits, guide staff and help those who are moving on.
In a discussion on Radio 4’s You & Yours programme with Alun Baker, founder of careers social network WYGU.com, Dr Hughes lamented the Connexions cuts but also felt that career platforms such as WYGU had a strong role to play in the evolution of careers advice.
She said: "I think it’s really to understand that the web is there and so many of us use it in our everyday lives. The important thing is making sure that individuals can cope with the volume of information and the differing websites. There are many organisations that are beginning to produce online careers resources and as an Institute, we greatly welcome that."
In the discussion, Alun Baker emphasised big differences between social network careers advice/HR platforms like WYGU.com and the Connexions service, likening his development to "a Facebook for careers".
Alun told listeners that the aim is to provide precise guidance for people of all ages, from starting out to changing and developing careers – "what people want is to connect with experts, to talk to the right people in those fields".
However, HR professionals need to know that these resources are safe, secure and effective. Dr Hughes emphasised that earlier online careers websites had highlighted the need for quality, safety and security.
In that context, Skills Minister John Hayes recently announced initiatives to build confidence in the mixed-sector approach. Options include a new kite mark to recognise best career guidance services or a register of providers who meet highest standards.
John Hayes says: "Everyone knows that impartial advice is always the best advice. But that independent advice must also be underpinned by professional expertise. I want to re-professionalise the careers service and create an environment in which careers guidance is recognised for the important public good it is, in which young people, adults, schools, colleges, universities and whole communities see its value, use it and invest in it."
So, can online platforms redefine the careers advice terrain and give HR professionals the relevant engagement, conversion and continued guidance tools they will need in the next troubled decade?
Time and experience will narrate that story but it is certain that the black hole in careers advice and HR needs to be sealed before it sucks the life out of the UK economy. Effective online resources will play a significant part in that healing.
5 Responses
Careers advice needs revision to cater for the now society
I agree with Ed Nash (Humanita Ltd) there needs to be a mix. Careers advice is stuck in the dark ages with many services attempting to cater for young people or those pursuing undergraduate study.
Even then, in my experience with young people (16 – 24) who have approached me, careers advice is limited to what course is good to do because it is popular or has a media buzz about it. Advisors also appear very scripted in assessing how to advise. Sometimes because on paper, standard exam results appear lacking, advisors are directed advice seekers to a sometimes tedious level by level career climb which does not take into account individual’s ability, focus on the specific gap and or help the seeker manage their expectations.
Another issue is depending on your age, any kind of advice or steer is hit and miss because the people employed to provide the advice have a remit which caters for a certain demographic and are hesitant to go beyond that.
In this age of job losses, recognition of skills gaps, migration, an aging population and government initiatives to move the long term unemployed into work, advice needs to meet the needs of the society it is faced with.
The internet is useful for research and outreach. However, in the absence of the "human" approach, which will have the sympathy and empathy to coach and mentor vulnerable job seekers, returners to work and job changers into engaging in economic purposeful activity, careers advice will maintain it’s black hole.
Agree
Don’t get me wrong I completely agree with a mixed approach. My point is that the Internet isn’t currently part of the mix at all as quality content doesn’t tend to get there
Agree with a mix
The internet is a wonderful resource but without a face to face component especially for young people who are going through major life changes and are unsure of who they are yet it will be just as ineffective and possibly more misleading than other resources.
The internet on it’s own works well for those who know who they are; their strengths; skills and abilities. the very confident; the very focussed and motivated.
As we know that often how people present themselves on the web can be misleading or unrepresentative
Also Websites without a large interactive component also will succumb to the old computer adage GIGO (Garbage In; Garbage Out)
A Facebook type approach will seem attractive however the strength of contributions will need to be monitored closely especially for the vulnerable.
It Needs To Be A Mix
Everyone agrees that the internet gives several advantages to careers and job searchers not previously available. But just like networking, it needs to be face to face as well as over the ether as there are also many downsides to a Facebook type approach such as anger, criticism and people on soapboxes.
I have provided professional careers management services for over twenty years; the best combine strong mentoring with sympathy, empathy and great marketing techniques of which networking is by far the most effective.
Our site http://www.humanita.co.uk is moving towards being a centre of information coupled with a centre of excellence. Perhaps this might be one benchmark
— Ed Nash Humanita Ltd
Stuck in the dark ages
I recently did a project that looked at the quantity and quality of careers advice currently availbile online in the UK. My over riding conculsion was that the best careers advice content just doesn’t make it onto the internet at all. It seems to me that we are stuck in the dark ages in terms of careers advice and use of technology platforms in this country. The internet should be a mainstream channel not an optional extra or something careers professionals are scared of. At the moment this gap in "the market" is being filled by poor quality content which is often misleading and sometimes exploitative
Matt Alder
http://www.MetaShift.co.uk