Summary: When job adverts dress up basic legal entitlements as benefits, hide salary information and lean on hollow perks, employers are signalling a transactional rather than people-first culture before a candidate has even applied. Transparency is increasingly important to job seekers and misaligned expectations are fueling costly ghosting. Employers must rethink how appreciation shows up from the very first interaction.
A job advert is likely the first true interaction employers and prospective employees will have. Employers, naturally, use vacancy listings as a way to seek out top talent that best aligns with company values and required skills.
But job listings aren’t only advertising vacancies, they’re also advertising company culture. They often say more about a company’s attitude to employee appreciation than any careers page or employer brand campaign.
Yet a staggering number of organisations are sending the wrong signals to prospective employees. Our research reveals one in five job adverts dress up baseline legal rights as a ‘benefit’. At the same time, only 17 per cent of roles advertise a fixed salary, and almost one third provide no salary information at all.
When legal entitlements are presented as perks, what’s really being communicated is not generosity. It’s a misunderstanding of what appreciation actually means.
One in five job adverts dress up baseline legal rights as a ‘benefit’
Appreciation starts before day one
Appreciation is often framed as something that happens once someone has joined an organisation. But in reality, it starts much earlier.
When that first interaction via a job advert lacks clarity or leans on promoting basic entitlements as benefits, it sends a clear message: that the organisation sees the employment relationship as transactional rather than relational.
Candidates pick up on this quickly and are increasingly acting on it. Transparency is one of the most important deciding factors when it comes to considering applying for a job, with recent research revealing 80 per cent of job seekers wouldn’t apply for a role that didn’t clearly list pay.
The same is true for benefits. Employers are seeking more meaningful benefits that will truly improve their work/life balance. Flexible working, for example, continues to be one of the most in-demand benefits an employer can offer, with almost one-third of employees agreeing this is their main retention driver (31 per cent).
The hidden cost of misaligned messaging
When a job ad promises one thing, but the company culture delivers another, the problem goes beyond just attracting candidates. The hiring process sets up expectations that don’t match reality. This creates a misaligned understanding between employer and employee from day one.
New hires who find the reality does not match the promise must either spend their early months realigning their expectations or may simply begin looking for a new job. As a result, trust is weakened before it has a chance to fully form, and engagement becomes much harder to build.
According to an Indeed survey, 36 per cent of UK job seekers have ‘ghosted’ two to four employers over a 12-month period. That’s an expensive problem for recruiters, given it costs £6,125 on average to hire a single employee.
The top reasons for ghosting include:
- The job not being the right fit
- The company not being the right fit
- The pay offer not being enough
- Benefits lacking.
All of these reasons point toward a misalignment of expectations that could have been avoided with a more transparent job advert from the outset.
Beyond perks, manager recognition is the top driver of employee appreciation
Why ‘perks’ are missing the point
At the heart of this issue is a narrow view of appreciation. Where an organisation should be considering the individual as valuable for who they are, too often a candidate’s value is tied solely to what they can offer.
In fact, switching this mindset by taking an empathy first approach to HR can be better for business. Our studies have shown when employees feel appreciated and valued, they are 43 per cent more productive.
But how can HRs best make workers feel truly appreciated? Employee appreciation is frequently reduced to perks, benefits or rewards. And while these are good signifiers for candidates unfamiliar with the company culture at the attraction stage, they should not be the sole focus of an organisation’s appreciation strategy.
Beyond perks, manager recognition is the top driver of employee appreciation. Genuine recognition must be a part of everyday interactions. This is how companies can form a company culture that consistently values employees as people, not just as contributors to output.
That said, having hard work rewarded is still an important motivator for employees. Yet, with cost-of-living pressures straining budgets, it’s no surprise that many companies are leaning on superficial perks to attract top talent, rather than investing in meaningful rewards that truly resonate.
But rewarding employees doesn’t necessarily have to come at a high cost. When budgets are constrained, I’d recommend getting more creative and consider ways to reward employees without a high price tag.
For example, investing in their professional progression within the company through training programmes is an effective approach that simultaneously supports an employee’s growth while strengthening the organisation as a whole.
What an appreciation-led job advert looks like
So, what can employers do to better attract top talent?
A job advert that best demonstrates employee appreciation should always be clear, specific and honest. Being upfront about salary and avoiding inflated language is the bare minimum, and businesses need to strive to do better.
A truly effective advert should go beyond this. Away from surface-level benefits, the advert should instead answer the questions candidates actually care about, ie. how will I be supported here? How are decisions made? What does recognition look like in practice?
If an organisation positions itself as people-first, this should be present in how it communicates at every stage, including the initial job advert.
Transparency is part of that, but so is authenticity. Remember, candidates aren’t looking for perfect messaging, but they are looking for credible messaging.
Three key takeaways
- Misleading or vague job adverts create expectation gaps that can damage engagement, increase turnover and raise recruitment costs.
- Genuine employee appreciation goes beyond perks, with everyday recognition and supportive management playing a bigger role in engagement and productivity.
- Effective job adverts should be honest, specific and focused on what candidates truly value. For example, culture, support and opportunities for growth.
Did you find this article interesting? Check out your next read: An HR guide to retaining knowledge (and talent) through career fluidity
